The Western Transportation Corridor

State and Federal financing of transportation infrastructure skews development in Prince William County - but not everyone agrees with that perspective. On February 1, 2001, the Senate Transportation Committee "passed by indefintely" SB 1326, thus killing a bill for "Evaluation of Highway Construction Impacts" sponsored by State Senator R. Edward Houck. Houck, representing Spottsylvania County, wanted the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) to study how new roads and road improvements (such as interchanges) affected rural regions in particular:
"The Department of Transportation shall evaluate the effectiveness and impact of all proposed new highways, new lanes added to existing highways, and new interchanges, wherever such proposed projects are estimated to cost $20 million or more by modeling and forecasting the traffic and land-use impacts of such projects. Traffic impacts to be studied shall include, but not necessarily be limited to, the additional number of vehicle trips and vehicle miles driven that the new facility will generate, inducing drivers to use the new facility instead of alternative transportation modes or alternative routes, or by changing development patterns. Land-use impacts shall include, but not necessarily be limited to, the new facility's impact on the pace and location of new development and population distribution, which can result in the need for additional school, sewer, and transportation infrastructure. The Department shall conduct the evaluations required by this section during the preliminary engineering phase of a project, and shall conduct them in conjunction with other review processes applicable to all proposed projects whenever possible. The Department shall report the results of its modeling and forecasts under this section to the Commonwealth Transportation Board and to the governing body of all affected counties, cities, and towns."

Speaking in opposition, State Senatoe Malfourd W. Trumbo said "There's a good chance if this passes VDOT then starts driving land-use." That's exactly the concern, according to the smart growth activists. Improving the infrastructure for cars will induce more drivers to use their cars and reduce demand for mass transit. New roads such as the proposed Western Transportation Corridor may do little to reduce existing congestion. Instead, they spread congestion further into the rural regions, spurring sprawl.

Houck was a Democrat, Trumbo was a Republican. The bill was rejected on a party-line vote, 9 Republicans opposed and 6 Democrats in favor. Several Republicans, such as State Senator Bill Mims, represent districts impacted by sprawl. Sprawl activists unable to address the issue at a stateway level will naturally focus on local issues, such as the Western Transportation Corridor. Look for letters such as:

Like french fries with your meal? What if you were provided another serving of french fries, and then another? At first, the extra potatoes might be a welcome addition... and if you could choose mashed or baked potatoes as well, that would be a bonus. But at some point, you'll want more than potatoes, right?

Roads in Northern Virginia are like french fried potatoes. "More" is a good thing, but only up to a point. Then you want some balance in your diet.

Current proposals to finance more roads with taxes (or bonds to be funded by taxes) makes no more sense than buying a dozen side dishes of potatoes. Sure, we might get some rail, bus, and other mass transit along with the roads... but we need to invest in more than transportation proposals that come in fried, mashed, or half-baked varieties.

In addition to transportation improvements, we need to consider where we invest in housing, and where we encourage jobs. If we focus growth in selected areas, then we'll feel better. We can do this by tax incentives for locating jobs and housing where the infrastructure is already in place, or disincentives for building in undeveloped areas, rather than subsidizing new pathways for new subdivisions.

If we use our scarce tax dollars to finance the Western Transportation Corridor to increase sprawl in Northern Virginia, then we deserve the indigestion that comes with an unbalanced diet. If we revitalize the Route 1 Corridor instead of create a new transportation corridor, we'll be able to relax and enjoy life. And that's not a small-potato issue...

Links


Highways in Virginia
Sprawl in Virginia
Prince William County
Geography of Virginia